*My annual reports are on Google Plus, where nobody reads them.
According to the Canada Revenue Agency, I'm a profitable small business. The only thing preventing me from spending it all on iPads, Google Glasses and Surface Tablets is the fact that I have to feed my lovely family.
I keep costs down by feeding them chocolate flavoured soylent in a bucket
Here's some tips on running a business in Canada selling software to Americans.
Incorporation
Incorporation is a good choice. While it gives a valuable sense of security (albeit false) against lawsuits, the most useful benefit is income deferral. I started this company while I was working full time. If it were a sole proprietorship, I would have had to pay the top tax rate of 40% on everything I earned. This would have been a huge disincentive to growing my business.
Evil Tip for starting a company while working somewhere else
Whenever someone asks if it's legal, point them to the corporate policy and claim that there's a simple form that you fill out, and loudly complain that it takes the legal department eight months to answer any emails. With luck, the person that asked will launch into his own stories about the slow legal department, thus deflecting the conversation to a more useful topic.
With all of the profits inside a corporation, I had to pay only the 16% corporate tax on them. But I can keep the profits there until I feel like withdrawing them. It's like having an extra RRSP.
However, incorporation does have some added responsibilities. First, I have to pay Intuit TurboTax $200 every year to file my taxes. And that software only does about 10% of the work -- I have to maintain a balance sheet and income statement for the year so I can get the numbers to enter into TurboTax. Still, I figure we are about even, because Intuit also bought the server edition of WebsequenceDiagrams.
Evil Tip for doing your own taxes
It is easy to make a lot of mistakes the first time. But hiring an accountant costs $2000, while penalties from the government for making a mistake are maybe about $50 tops. I'll re-evaluate this when I'm making sufficiently more profit.
After you incorporate, you can't do very much until you get:
A business bank account
Canada has a cartel of five major banks. Stay away from them. I was explaining banking to my 3 year old daughter (her twitter account):
Me: Banks are a place where you keep your money.
Lillian: WHY?
Me: Because they give you interest... (thinking) but then they take it away and charge you more money.
Lillian: WHY?
Me: I guess you put your money in a bank to keep it safe, and every month they take some away.
Lillian: WHY?
Me: I don't know. If you keep your money in the bank they will slowly take it away from you.
Lillian: I WILL KEEP MY MONIES BESIDE MY POTTY.
Me: Good. Now it's time to watch Dora. Daddy's got to go buy some bitcoin.
Instead, I use a local credit union, which has a pay-as-you go account. For $5 a month I can keep all of my profits there and write cheques. They wanted to sell me a business cheque book. What is it with all these leather-bound things? Does my business have to have everything wrapped in cow skin to appear successful? I imagine it might be useful in a narrow range of situations:
Me in line at the grocery store: Will you take a cheque for these RufflesTM brand potato chips?
Attractive cashier: Um, noooo. What do you think this is, like 1985? Don't you have a Paypass chip?
Me: What about... from THIS chequebook? (whips out the corinthian leather-bound Execu-Check 5000 with dual-signature, day-planner, and matching gold pens.)
Attractive cashier: Oooh, no problem, Mr. Hanov. What are you doing later?
My wife: He'll be sleeping in the basement. Let's go.
I managed to get them to give me personal cheques with my business name written on them by asking very nicely. Credit unions are nice that way.
Unfortunately you have to deal with big banks sometimes. I needed to get:
A credit card
After a lot of research, I selected the Bank of Montreal credit card for businesses, because there is no fee and every December I get some cash back for using it. I filled out the application with my personal information, and since I was working at the time, there was no problem getting it.
Evil tip for paying for things
Currency exchange is expensive. As a rule, I pay for US things with US dollars, and Canadian things with Canadian dollars. This was only a problem with Microsoft Office 365, which insisted on charging my Paypal account in CAD. I had to tell Microsoft that I live in Beverly Hills to use my USD Paypal account. Because that's the only zip code I know.
I've only talked about the Canadian side so far. But many Canadian software companies get all their revenue in US dollars. There is an important trick for dealing with this, which I will get to shortly. But first:
Paypal
Paypal is utterly horrible to use and develop for. For example, to cancel a subscription for a user from last August, I have to page through them all, 25 at a time, waiting 5-10 seconds for each page load, until I get to August. If I didn't know when the subscription started, then I would be there for much longer reading all of the names. For developers, Paypal offers a special sandbox area which hasn't worked in months, and special paypal IPN notifications which are broken for several months out of the year.
But once it's finally working, Paypal works everywhere. It lets me enter in tax rates for all of the Canadian provinces and territories (Why aren't they there already?). It lets me accept orders from Israel, France, the UK, Germany, Australia, New Zealand, Finland, Norway. When companies that I sell to refuse to use Paypal, it lets me pay $35 to enter the credit card details manually. The fee is outrageous, but it's a steal compared to anywhere else I can use. (Update: Use stripe.com.
I use Paypal for most of my sales, but I have a small nagging fear that one day, the US Government, (which to us Canadians appears quite insane, so they would do this kind of thing) will take all of my money one day to fight terror by arming day cares. But when I transfer money out of Paypal into Canada, they use over-the-counter exchange rates. If you are using Paypal for currency-conversion you must stop immediately, because there is a better way, which I will explain to you shortly.
But first, to get the money out of Paypal without currency conversion, you need:
A US dollar bank account
My credit union couldn't offer all the services I needed to run my global company. I searched around and I found a reasonable deal with the Royal Bank of Canada USD Checking account. It is regularly $9/month, but with a minimum balance of $2500 the price drops to $2.
I need the USD bank account so I can accept incoming bank transfers with no currency losses. Outside of North America, it is common to pay for large items by exchanging bank account information, so the buyer can transfer the cash directly into the seller's accounts. North American banks discourage this behaviour by levying huge fees. When I invoice a customer, I include the bank details and in a few weeks I receive the full amount, minus the $15 fee for RBC, and $25 for some mysterious "intermediary bank". Still, a flat $40 charge looks pretty good on amounts greater than $1000 when compared to Paypal's fees for the same.
Evil tip for well-connected, wealthy European financiers
An intermediary bank is a good business to get into. Also, drugs.
So I have a Canadian Dollar account in a credit union, US dollars in Paypal, and US dollars in RBC. How do I get my money into good old Canadian loonies and toonies? That's where my favourite part comes in.
XE.com
If you are a Canadian company whose revenue comes in USD, you should immediately get an account at a currency broker. Once set up, it is a simple matter to transfer money between a US and Canadian bank account, at crazy-low conversion fees.
For example, I just went to Paypal and XE and priced out transferring $5000 USD into Canada. Today, the difference is not huge, but the spread has been much higher in the past.
Paypal | $4,929.33 CAD |
XE.com | $4,980.00 CAD |
I do not want 1 to 3% of my revenue disappearing off the top, so I use XE. When I signed up, I registered my US account and the Canadian one with them by copying the numbers off some cheques, and now I can initiate a transfer in seconds.
Charging tax
I added this section due to the comments. As a Canadian, if you make more than $30,000 in revenue in a year or recently (See the CRA web site for specific rules) then you have to register for GST/HST. You may register before that time though, and it may be advantageous, because registered businesses don't pay GST / HST. Keep track of all the stuff you buy for your business, tell the CRA the total each January, and you will get it all back in a nice fat cheque. This works out well when you, for instance, buy a $5000 Macbook pro.
Registering for GST/HST, however, requires you to do certain things.
- Fill out the GST/HST return each year. It is a simple two-page form. Just report your total sales, the tax you collected, and the tax you paid. That's it!
- When you invoice a Canadian customer, then include your HST registration number and the tax charged in the invoice. This varies by province, so make sure you look it up on Wikipedia before you invoice those freeloading Albertans.
You aren't obligated to collect taxes for the governments of other countries. Just invoice the subtotal, and they can work out their own damn taxes. This does lead to a ridiculous HST return, where you've collected $100k in revenue and only $100 in HST. That's OK... software is a global product, and there are hardly any Canadians in this global market.
Do you charge in US dollars? That's OK too. It may look weird, but you can invoice a Canadian in USD. I do this because all my accounts are set up in USD. Also include HST in USD on the amount, as if it were in CAD. For reporting purposes, I convert the total based on the yearly average USD conversion rate on the CRA web site, but you are free to use other methods.
In January you will have to pay, or receive, the difference in taxes you collected and taxes you paid for stuff.
How do you do it?
Do you have a different way for optimizing your cash flow? Did I miss anything? Please share your tips in the comments.
Email Etiquette
If you begin your emails with "Hi, <name>!" then they will seem less rude.
How a programmer reads your resume (comic)
People thought it was a comic, so I never corrected them.
Why Perforce is more scalable than Git
Branching on Perforce is kind of like performing open heart surgery. But here's why git can't hope to compete with it.
UMA's dirty secrets
Recently, many carriers have started offering UMA, or WiFi phones. These are cell phones with WiFi capabilites. Don't be fooled -- you won't be able to get free calls and run skype on them. The UMA technology is meant to extend the carrier's cellular network into your home using your broadband internet connection.
Asana's shocking pricing practices, and how you can get away with it too
If one apple costs $1, how much would five apples cost? How about 500? If everyday life, when you buy more of something, you get more bananas for your buck. But software companies are bucking the trend.
Four ways of handling asynchronous operations in node.js
Javascript was not designed to do asynchronous operations easily. If it were, then writing asynchronous code would be as easy as writing blocking code. Instead, developers in node.js need to manage many levels of callbacks.
Today, we will examine four different methods of performing the same task asynchronously, in node.js.
See sound without drugs
I have created an application that just turns on the microphone and continually plots the FFT magnitude of what it records. It allows control over the window size and sampling rate.
20 lines of code that will beat A/B testing every time
A/B testing is used far too often, for something that performs so badly. It is defective by design: Segment users into two groups. Show the A group the old, tried and true stuff. Show the B group the new whiz-bang design with the bigger buttons and slightly different copy. After a while, take a look at the stats and figure out which group presses the button more often. Sounds good, right? The problem is staring you in the face. It is the same dilemma faced by researchers administering drug studies. During drug trials, you can only give half the patients the life saving treatment. The others get sugar water. If the treatment works, group B lost out. This sacrifice is made to get good data. But it doesn't have to be this way.
Zwibbler: A simple drawing program using Javascript and Canvas
Now it's a commercial product, but
Zwibbler was once a fun side-project, and here's some details on its implementation.
Spoke.com scam
Rant: Why do companies think they can make money by posting false information about you on the Internet?